Tuesday, 17 November 2026

NYCFC and Red Bulls Both Miss MLS Playoffs as New Stadium Tops Out

For the first time since NYCFC joined MLS in 2015, neither New York club will play in the playoffs, even as construction of NYCFC's Etihad Park reaches a key milestone.

NYCFC and Red Bulls Both Miss MLS Playoffs as New Stadium Tops Out

New York's two Major League Soccer clubs will both sit out the postseason this year, the first time this has happened since New York City FC joined the league in 2015, according to an analysis published by GOAL.

Neither NYCFC nor the New York Red Bulls qualified for the playoffs. GOAL says this deepens the league's long-running difficulty in winning over its largest market.

The disappointing season has come as NYCFC marks progress on Etihad Park, its long-awaited soccer-specific stadium. Hundreds of people, including construction workers, union members, club staff, fans, executives and journalists, attended a topping-off ceremony at the site.

In the traditional ceremony, a tree is placed on a steel beam, which a crane then lifts to the top of the structure. The placing of the final beam, GOAL wrote, effectively signals the beginning of a new chapter for football in the city.

Also read: Fullkrug Delighted by Germany Recall Ahead of Nations League Games

Both clubs have enjoyed recent success. NYCFC won MLS Cup in 2021 and reached the Eastern Conference final last season, while the Red Bulls made it to MLS Cup in 2024. GOAL argues the harder task is converting those results into a lasting bond with the city's sporting public.

The outlet describes New York as having an unusually dense and diverse football following, with millions of residents supporting European giants such as Manchester United, Liverpool, Real Madrid, Arsenal, Chelsea and Barcelona. Paris Saint-Germain even has a shop on Fifth Avenue.

However, GOAL says local clubs have for years found it difficult to channel that enthusiasm towards themselves. It points out that the city's mayor, Zohran Mamdani, is a keen supporter of the sport, yet the professional men's teams at both USL and MLS level are, in its view, too often known for dysfunction.

The analysis suggests that trophies alone are not enough to build loyalty, arguing that fans need an identity and a journey to rally behind, rather than simply supporting a club because "they win stuff."

GOAL concludes that another season without either New York side in the postseason makes it harder for the clubs to establish themselves at the centre of the city's sporting life.

Source: GOAL. This story was prepared with the help of AI from that reporting, and checked by our editors.

Related stories

Comments

Sign in to join the conversation.